Example 1: The runner that mattered
A trader takes off two-thirds of every position at plus one R and lets a third run. On most trades this is fine. But on the one trade in twenty that runs to plus eight R, they only had a third of the size on for the big move, so they captured far less of the winner that was supposed to pay for all the small losses. Across the year, the smoother ride came at the cost of a noticeably lower total return, because the partials shrank exactly the trades the edge depended on. The fix was not to stop scaling, but to scale less on the setups with the biggest tails.
